Systemic Exclusion of Youth in Pakistan. (Part 1)

The following discussion is part of a series of threads that will be initiated by the Stewards of the South Asia ebpdn representing India, Bangladesh, Nepal and Pakistan. Each thread will run for a period of three weeks, lead by Barkat Shah from the Institute for Development Studies and Practices in Pakistan. During this time it will be open for comment to all members of the network. At the end of the designated three weeks, the discussion will be summarized and available on the network as a resource for members to download, while the discussion will still be available on the forum.

The Next Generation report produced by British council reveals that, half the population {of Pakistan} is under twenty years and 66% are less than thirty years. This lot of youth generates a hopes and aspirations in the minds especially for the infusing new vision and energies for stable, peaceful, just and self reliant Pakistani state and society. This is possible if they are provided spaces to be bolstered technically and conceptually so that to lead process of national development as practitioners, thinkers and leader. At present, this generation faces grave problems. The average young person in Pakistan is starved of education, livelihood opportunities, and currently a huge lot of urban and rural poor are

vulnerable to the manipulation of vested interest groups as to become part of the slave labor, underpaid employments, drugs and criminal violent activities both nationally and internationally.

Due to the inadequacies educational system and exclusive policies and practices 80 percent of young and energetic population does not reach to college level, more than 50 percent leaves schools half way or does not go to any educational institutions. The ones who attend schools ends up as literates but not educated. Thus majority of this young population is outside the formal system of education.. There is need to regenerate community based social development spaces for a meaningful livelihood and a chance for understanding the world they all live in. There is a very important need for regenerating positiveness in the lives of majority people of Pakistan and particularly Baluchistan who happens to be young and in large number but are pushed outside the system.

According to Population Council, an international, nonprofit, nongovernmental organization Youth in the poorest quartile also marry earlier and want more children than those in the richest quartile. It also reveals that Less than one-half of all young females ages 15-24 have ever enrolled in school—and of those who are enrolled, females are more likely than males to drop out at an earlier grade. Only 40 percent of rural Pakistani young women seek health care during their first pregnancy. Due to low income capacity 36 percent of this group has never attended school, while nearly 50 percent of boys in the lowest economic quartile start working before age 15.

In order to understand and articulate, the problems of youth exclusion from the mainstream process of education, development, and livelihood and over all policy making it are instrumental to pose some questions which will be instrumental to contextualize and organize the on-line discussion thread on the issue mentioned.

What are the factors that prevent a majority of youth from the educational practices in Pakistan?

What can be the potential issues that constrain youth participation in the mainstream process of development, livelihood and political processes?

How can the majority of socially and economically deprived youth are included as potential source of economic and political regeneration in the country?

If we believe that legislative process can bring a policy shift for ensuring the participation of youth in the mainstream development, learning and livelihood, what kind of possible actions should be carried out?

Posted 05 April 2010 by Barkat Shah Kakar from web

reply

forward

The major factor is poverty that is preventing majority of youth in Pakistan. Basic Facilities are out of reach of more then 80% of the population. Child labor, women violence are the basic problems here due to lack of education. The growing population is main hurdle in the developmental avenues. The main constrain that keep the youth in educational and developmental process is to support them financially. Different awareness programs in the rural areas and free access to the schools can engage our youth towards development

posted 20 April 2010 by Tahira from web

reply

forward

There are so many factors which prevent majority of youth from the educational process in the country. Especially in the case of Pakistan it become more important to analyses and renew the existing systems and process. Because we are a young country as the majority (65 %) of population are youth and young. Unfortunately we have not any sustainable plan or directions which help our majority to become a successful man in the society.
Here we will discuss that, what are the factors which prevent majority of youth from education process and practices.

The curricula and related pedagogy of education are usually inappropriate or at least inadequate for the set goals in many disciplines. Furthermore, there is no integrated system in which one step leads to the next to enable a student to develop a truly sound base for the discipline he or she is interested in. Moreover, even at the higher levels of education, there is no mechanism worth its name to help a student in gauging his or her potential or in deciding on a suitable academic career.

there are so many system working in the field of promoting education like Madrasa, Government schools, Privet schools, English medium schools, Urdu medium schools and so many. These are nothing but the main thing is that these all are creating different cultures and classes. Students coming out of English medium schools, especially good private sector schools, have little awareness of the society, culture and their own values whereas those passing out from Urdu medium schools are usually destined to work in clerical and lower level positions. Religious madrasas churn out yet another class that is usually unaware of the world outside their own and modern disciplines are usually unequipped to interact meaningfully with the larger society and are also monumental at times in spreading sectarianism.
There is not any link or synergy in-between educational system/ school and indigenous culture of the society. There for school is not made the part of society while all focus is on system, hard disciplines, undermining the mother language, irrelevant pedagogies, promoting an atmosphere of silence and exclusion based policies.

This may not be as difficult as it seems. Some work may be required in forming the curricula and pedagogy, but the rest can be done just by including good and people centered policies. Where education can help them, not only gaining information but good values, strong knowledge and skills. And where education can help them for their livelihood. Where education provide them opportunities for earning a sustainable livelihoods.
Its mean shift is possible but it only can come from lower to higher but not from higher to lower.

Thanks
Saeed Shah

posted 21 April 2010 by myself from web

  Systemic Exclusion of Youth in Pakistan

reply

forward

The lot of population is living in urban areas and are suffering from unprotected manipulation of the vested groups which ugh them for slavery, drug addiction, crimes. The females are not allowed to have better education. There is a need og better reconstruction of the system, society and our community according to better needs and need to fill gaps in between it. Most of the population has hope that policy making system will be revised for their betterment. The unwanted social activities is depriving youth as far as Pakistan is concern. the system should bring resources in the reach of youth as to brighten their future and to enhance their intellectual quality.

Posted 23 April 2010 by Tahira from web

reply

forward

First of all I am very thankful of ebpdn which has proven the opportunity for view sharing with the world peoples' and after of this I think youth is one of the main plier which is very excluded from decision making bodies but I think there is strongly need that the we shall focus on youth’s involvement in policy making to help mainstream the role of the youth in development. Policies passed by our Leaders always impact on us and yet we the youth are not given consideration during policy making and policy implementation. Development initiatives are also a line where youth are sidelined because we are considered youth is immature and inexperienced. But in my points of view youth are mature, responsible, enthusiastic about new ideas, innovative, energetic' and have the potency to be involved in policy and development initiatives and need to reviewing of convectional laws, policies and development agenda that are hindrance to youth’s participation. As an academic institutions its the responsibility we shall push towards the review of conventional laws that are usually laid down to sideline the youth from participation on social, political and economic aspects of life. Represent the youth and make sure policies passed do not have a negative impact on their youthful life. It shall make sure that the development agenda incorporate the young generation.

Posted 24 April 2010 by Tahira from web

reply

forward

1. As regards the first question I think socio-economic conditions especially the poverty and backwardness play a crucial in preventing the youth from educational practices in Pakistan.
2. As for the role of the youth in development, livelihood political process is concerned I think the patriarchal structures that perpetuates in a hierarchical manner to a great extent curtails youth participation in development, livelihood and politics.
3. By the development of critical consciousnesses of the youth about the social, political and economic structures in an organized and institutional pattern can help in including the youth in political and social regeneration of the country.
4. Legislative actions of streamlining the educational system on free of all class, race, and gender, religious biases can be a potential action in this regard

Sadiq khan
Faculty Member
Academic Development Program
IDSP-Pakistan

Posted 24 April 2010 by Tahira from web

reply

forward

One reason to promote participation for ‘youth as an age group‘ (rather than any other conceptualization of youth) is a recognition of the systematic exclusion and disenfranchisement of young people in many contexts.

However, systematic exclusion is not reversed by simply giving young people a platform (though this is a start) if the power asymmetries and knowledge asymmetries between young people and adults are not considered and addressed.

These asymmetries can be addressed both by capacity building (but that capacity building has to take into account (1) and make sure it is framed in broad terms), and by careful design of engagement processes and activities*.

(*In particular, a serious engagement with youth participation involves choosing new modes of conversation will be more useful.

thanks
Asha sindho

Posted 26 April 2010 by myself from web

reply

forward

There has been a recent gradual shift from discussions about ―children as the ―victims of violence to ―youth as a ―threat to security and stability. In particular, there have been multiple assertions that a ―surging youth population or ―youth bulge – combined with unemployment, urbanization and other factors – can lead to violence and most recent analyses of conflict identify some form of ―youth factor in the generation or perpetuation of
violence. There is certainly statistical evidence of a connection between high relative youth populations and risk of armed conflict and this can therefore indicate which countries are
likely to be at higher risk of violent conflict and provide one means for prioritizing when and where governments and other partners should engage with youth to take preventative action.

Tahir Mehmood
Sindh University
Pakistan

Posted 26 April 2010 by myself from web

reply

forward

In today’s world the concepts of social interaction are redefining with development of new ideas and technologies. Young people are the future work force and earliest adopters of ICTs as well as having a powerful force for change. Youth is in fact the recipient of the policies so their voice should be properly propagated to people involved in the design and evaluation of youth related programs, strategies or policies. Youth everywhere are faced with the challenges of attempting to broaden their horizons and become global citizens, yet their infrastructure in not accommodating their desire and need. This is necessary to value the input of juvenile and communities in creating and implementing plans for tailored change in an atmosphere of consensus. There must be some framework, building upon existing good practices to identify where changes are required and helping young people to identify strengths and weaknesses in service provisions. The ICT vision and strategy should also focus on young people and not only just technology. For this to happen, it is important to develop both the ICT vision and strategy with the involvement of youth. The information age has modified the working, learning and social conditions for young people. Barriers once evident through time and space are now blurred and new networks of interaction have been came into account. More often it is the younger generations who feel more comfortable using ICTs to further expand their knowledge and information. The new wave of Information Society has provided young people with the tools to explore world otherwise unknown to them.

Seher Naz
seher124@yahoo.com

Posted 26 April 2010 by myself from web

reply

forward

The main reason that youth is away from education is poverty. A man from lower class or middle class can’t bare the expenses of education that are inflating day by day. The distribution of rights is totally unequal. Everyone around is fighting for bread and butter who cares about education. Pillars of our nation are week we can’t withstand with the today’s world demands. The democracy has demolished the equality of human rights. The youth got no interest in the politics they just want their rights and justice. The eligible persons are never preferred instead those who got best P.R and are eligible to pay donations are given priority. This distribution must be stop at once in order to provide a stage or platform to intellectual youth to expose their abilities...
Sana Tanzil
BS.Biotech
BUITEMS

Posted 27 April 2010 by Tahira from web

reply

forward

As I think that The most important risk factors preventing young people from participating in education beyond compulsory schooling are the language, the parents’ level of education and the place of residence

people who were unable to take up the training or education of their choice left education after nine years of compulsory schooling. In this context, the native language and the parents’ educational level also play a role: young people whose native language is a different language than Urdu / English and whose parents are less educated themselves are less often free to follow the educational or career path of their choice.

Socio-economic Condition also plays a major role in this regard-
Shabbir Ahmed
Resource Centre incharge
IDSP-Pakistan

Posted 27 April 2010 by Tahira from web

reply

forward

The youth is the majority population in the country and lack of opportunities has curtailed their efforts to play an active role in the process of development in a positive manner. The Formal set up through its exploitative mechanism has excluded majority of the youth / young from mainstream educational or other skill development process that might have enabled them to earn their livelihood and play a meaningful role in the overall development process.
The ultimate result of all of this confusion has created a vacuum that is filled by the vested interests to forward their own agenda. Therefore, Young/ youth are used as a fuel in the ongoing surge of militancy and extremism. If not dealt properly, the negative impacts may spread further leaving the province, country and even the whole region in a state of perpetual violence and chaos.

Saeed

Posted 27 April 2010 by myself from web

reply

forward

Young people constitute the largest [66%] resides between the age 15-35] segment of Pakistani population. Especially those from low and middle income groups, have few opportunities to develop to their full potential. Poverty is widespread, education levels are low, youth unemployment is high and traditional culture does not encourage young people to take decisions on issues concerning concern them. There is limited scope for young people’s positive local engagement in grassroots politics and community development.
The emergence of Taliban and the event of 9/11 on the other hand, gave new birth to the phenomena of Jihad and political radicalization among Pakistani youth. The situation becomes more complex when it arrives to the reality of youth of traditional societies such as Balochistan and NWFP.

Nevertheless formal education systems too are not creating mass level awareness regarding intensive engagement in the civic life. They neither have the capacity to comprehend these situations in its totality, nor capable to take the challenges of recreating spaces of dialogue and interactions which help young people to streamline their role in the making of democratic societies. Consequently societies keep losing its potential and strength for a progressive democracy and civic culture.

Khalil Kakar
Quetta Pakistan

Posted 27 April 2010 by myself from web

reply

forward

The large population of Pakistani youth is a most vulnerable, because there is no proper social, educational and livelihood system for youth. The majority of youth are becoming drop out after the middle and matriculation. Because the education system could not cover their needs. Lake of opportunities, having no cultural spaces, no direction, no self awareness, critical and analytical skills and no mentoring is the key reasons of the youth. Currently the youth of the country are becoming attached with different religious and sectarian militancy movements. An acceptance of extremism has being developed in common people of the area and especially in youth. Several youth has been the part of suicidal attacks. It is a fact that the negative opportunities, spaces, communication channels, source of entertainments, company, knowledge and directions are comparatively less then positive above things.

Ahmed Ali
Sindh Language Academy
Sindh

posted 27 April 2010 by myself from web

reply

forward

I think only systems are not responsible. My point is that, systematic exclusion has strong linkages with social exclusion. Which is deeply rooted in the social, economic and political experience of Pakistan? Fundamentally, systematic exclusion refers to the relationship between citizens and the state. Other development concepts such as poverty, vulnerability, deprivation and inequality do not imply causality, whereas a social exclusion framework implies that someone or something is doing the excluding. Social exclusion is thus relational, and is embedded in the formal and informal institutions of a society, deriving from social relations founded on differences in status or power. In Pakistan, some of the main barriers to poverty reduction & social change lie precisely in social and institutional relations.

Rihan Malik
student
Rawalpindi
Pakistan

Posted 27 April 2010 by myself from web

reply

forward

Dear Tahira,

Thanks for sharing these valuable questions.
I think these are the questions, worth of more consideration. For resolving the stated problem it is required to be found the answers to the stated questions, and actions are required to be taken for the implementation what the answers demand.

The main factors of youth exclusion from educational practices are present education system, lake of awareness, economic condition, and lake of social mobilization regarding education.
As there are basic weaknesses in our education system. It has no coordination with socio-economic condition of the country. First it can't attract youth, then fails to involve youth into the process of development, politics and livelihood.
The entire education system of Pakistan needs to be changed to resolve the above stated problems. The education ought to be integrated with the social, cultural, economic, geographic, demographic conditions and needs of the region.

Integration of education to the real needs and conditions of the country, and awareness are the solutions according to my point of view.

Regards
Salam Kakar
Admin Officer
Zaanth Project
Loralai Pakistan

Posted 28 April 2010 by myself from web

reply

forward

Dear Saeed,
Sol q1) The main reasons behind the youth exclusion are as follows
1: From the very beginning the children who then become the youth, lack the confidence of decision making as parents do not care of children participation in their childhood which directly effects the decisions making in the choice of study they want to make thus caught in worries and distress. The major factors behind every success are interest in that field. Let the youth decide itself and then see what he contributes in the development of that country.
Regards,
Naveed Khoro
Project Manager
Child Protection Quetta

Posted 28 April 2010 by myself from web

reply

forward

Poverty, illiteracy, corruption, feudalism, confused education system and unfair distribution of resources are the major factors preventing youth from education practices in Pakistan.
The lack of awareness regarding their basic rights ,carelessness from their basic duties, lack of patience and understandability of things going around, their dependency on their parents, not following the opportunities in accordance to their talent rather availing the one providing more income. Diversified though confused thoughts regarding their success and life, lack of enthusiasm. They ere the prisoners of brutal life they are provided with and not willing to come out or to create any change, self lippy, limited opportunities as per population and fields, prevalence of cheating and use of influences
by creating or forming a number of groups continuously including youth in some healthy activity will not raise their confidence but also groom their talent. the existing social groups must inform about their existence and its members should aware and motivate others to be a part of it. by enhancing and working on the education system and making the youth more knowledgeable rather than educated through still illiterate industries and different organization must increase their rate of providing intern ships in order to benefits from the new ideas of youth and should help them economical but in a noble way that is by the use of their talent and appreciating it. The educated youth must be trained to to some creative or skilled work by the government and then introduced in the main stream to increase their confidence level
Different educational and skilled centre should be fully supported (either financially or morally) by the government. Steps to improve educational policies must be taken in order to save the youth from a paternalistic approach. Introducing programs to offer a handsome amount of money to the youth who are skilled and capable of doing good work.
Johum Sarfaraz Ali
BS.Biotech
BUITEMS

Posted 28 April 2010 by Tahira from web

reply

forward


1. What are the factors that prevent a majority of youth from the educational practices in Pakistan?

Many factors are at work in the prevent a majority of youth from the educational practices in Pakistan

As we having a long tradition of exchanging information and ideas to our generation they understand the history of our civilization in education it is not practices

Not relevant with geographical realities and mother tongue.

Syllabus is lengthy not deviated in semester wise.

May be education was not on need of the youth and education did not solve the issues of youth.

2. What can be the potential issues that constrain youth participation in the mainstream process of development, livelihood and political processes?

Many factors are at work in the growth and development process, but in the long run, a country's prosperity and the welfare of its people are determined by the pace of accumulating physical and human capital, by how efficiently the capital is used, and by how equitable access is to opportunities that growth and development generate.

Vulnerability, and human security have become dominant

themes of on-going academic debates on sustainable livelihoods and rural dynamics

Religious movements is one of important factor now a days.

3. How can the majority of socially and economically deprived youth be included as potential source of economic and political regeneration in the country?

The concept does not describe a new reality; neither is it is the only appropriate or even a radically innovative concept to describe deprivation.

Country law and regulation did not give permission to the youth that they exclude in future and take spates forward.

Lack of opportunities in state.

4. If we believe that legislative process can bring a policy shift for ensuring the participation of youth in the mainstream development,learning and livelihood, what kind of possible actions should be carried out?

A review of youth-serving organizations and the specific services they provide.

A survey of economic opportunities.

A force for peace, democracy, equality and good governance.

Freedom of expression and the protection of human rights

Respect for diversity and human dignity and opposition to all forms of

discrimination whether based on age, political affiliation, social status, marital status, race, ethnicity.

Upholding international agreements on peace and security, the rule of international law and opposition to terrorism and all forms of extremism.

Strengthening, enhancing and supporting the role of young people in conflict management and the promotion of a Commonwealth culture of peace ensured in respect and mutual understanding.

Promoting a supportive environment including family, kinship and community networks as core contributors to youth well being and development;

Advocating for the development of indigenous capital, research and technology and the promotion of cultural heritage and values as enablers of youth development.

Regards

Naheed

posted yesterday by Tahira from web

reply

forward

The basic reason is Poverty and Negligence of parents. The future of a child depends upon brought up of a child. If his or her brought up is done in a good educated environment the result obviously will be good. But in today's era the poverty is the main hurdle .
Our leaders don't want to share their experience sincerely with the youth because they don't want to loose their dominance, they want to be dominant forever and don't want the new people to come forward and take over them as a result youth is not participating in politics and developmental practices. To make the participation of youth assure in different areas. The tribal system is making the future of youth dark the tribal leaders thought that if their young generation get education their ruling system will be ruined to secure their dominance they are diprieving youth and keeping them away from all developmental practices.
If youth play their positive role and if they are allowed to take part in the different social and economic practices then we can hope for the better future of our country but their must be unity and integrity.
Roqaiyah Kamal
IDSP_PAKISTAN

posted yesterday by Tahira from web

reply

forward

The main factors that are keeping our youth away from education include:
1. Education System
2. Family Environment
3. Teachers behavior
4. Parents Negligence
5. Taking Interest in odd activities
6. seats division and lack of national integrity.
The political system has depressed our youth in this way that their interests are totally damaged now and they usually keep their self away from these type of practices and dividing them in different seats and they are loosing their national integrity. The deprived youth really need support of government and need social exposure they must be given special attention to indulge them in different developmental projects. The differences between them must be wash out in order to develop a sense of unity and integrity.
First of all there is a need of better and equally distributed education system. Resolve the problem of unemployment, there must be equal n justified distribution of education system and it must made in reach of everyone. The social differences must be filled in in order to create an environment of understanding and unity.
Noor Bano
IDSP-Pakistan

posted yesterday by Tahira from web

reply

forward

The most important and common factor that prevent youth from the educational practices in Pakistan is biasedness among citizens only those who have strong financial and political background can participate and avail all kind of opportunities where they can practice their educational expertise. most of our youth are unable to avail such opportunities.

An other factor is that as we all know that Pakistan is a third world developing country and per cap ta income is below from average line so it is difficult for most of individuals to equip their young by latest education, thus, these are the factors that prevent youth from the educational practices in Pakistan.

Favoritism, unequal opportunities, prejudices, tribal system can be the potential issues that causes constrain for youth in participation in the mainstream process of development,livelihood and political processes, if these issues being discouraged then wothfull youth will come in front and participate in all important socio- economic issues and will boost the economy of the country ultimately.
If we want economic and political regeneration in the country we have to encourage and welcome talented and educated young generation to come in front and participate in all important activities for the economic and political development of the country and we have to ensure that discrimination on geographical, demo graphical bases should be eradicated

Thanks i hope that my participation in this discussion will help you to some extent

Imr@n
IDSP-Pakistan

posted yesterday by Tahira from web

reply

forward

1. What are the factors that prevent a majority of youth from the educational practices in Pakistan?

Cynicism Amongst youth

Motivation

Awareness

Teachers behaviors

poverty

pents not paying attention to the children

What can be the potential issues that constrain youth participation in the mainstream process of development,livelihood and political processes?
Review of literature theoretical and conceptual.

Analysis the Rules and regulation in Pakistan of youth

conduct meeting with youth and asses their needs

3. How can the majority of socially and economically deprived youth be included as potential source of economic and political regeneration in the country?

Engage the youth in different issues

Social and political exclusion

cultural instruments

local and civil government rules

violation of human right rules in country

4. If we believe that legislative process can bring a policy shift for ensuring the participation of youth in the maiWhat are the factors that prevent a majority of youth from the educational practices in Pakistan?

Cynicism Amongst youth

Motivation

Awareness

Teachers behaviors

poverty

pents not paying attention to the children

What can be the potential issues that constrain youth participation in the mainstream process of development,livelihood and political processes?What are the factors that prevent a majority of youth from the educational practices in Pakistan?

Cynicism Amongst youth

Motivation

Awareness

Teachers behaviors

poverty

pents not paying attention to the children

What can be the potential issues that constrain youth participation in the mainstream process of development,livelihood and political processes?

Review of literature theoretical and conceptual.

Analysis the Rules and regulation in Pakistan of youth

conduct meeting with youth and asses their needs

3. How can the majority of socially and economically deprived youth be included as potential source of economic and political regeneration in the country?

Engage the youth in different issues

Social and political exclusion

cultural instruments

local and civil government rules

violation of human right rules in country

4. If we believe that legislative process can bring a policy shift for ensuring the participation of youth in the maiWhat are the factors that prevent a majority of youth from the educational practices in Pakistan?

Cynicism Amongst youth

Motivation

Awareness

Teachers behaviors

poverty

pents not paying attention to the children

What can be the potential issues that constrain youth participation in the mainstream process of development,livelihood and political processes?

Review of literature theoretical and conceptual.

Analysis the Rules and regulation in Pakistan of youth

conduct meeting with youth and asses their needs

3. How can the majority of socially and economically deprived youth be included as potential source of economic and political regeneration in the country?

Engage the youth in different issues

Social and political exclusion

cultural instruments

local and civil government rules

violation of human right rules in country

4. If we believe that legislative process can bring a policy shift for ensuring the participation of youth in the mainstream development,learning and livelihood, what kind of possible actions should be carried out?

Provide youth with opportunities to

master core literacy and numeracy skills,

basic employability and life skills, and

vocational skills. They can be designed as

a second chance pathway to a primary or

secondary school degree, an opportunity

to gain the skills needed to return to formal

education, or a vehicle to acquire the skills

needed to get a job or start a business.

Build upon the existing knowledge

and experience of participating youth

and relate these to the predominant

household livelihood strategies.

Allow participants to make educational

gains or earn achievement certifications in

manageable blocks, offering flexibility in pacing classes and allowing students to

easily enter and leave programs) to youth

and their families who must often defer or

interrupt educational pursuits to address

day-to-day survival needs.

Regards.

noreen amber

posted yesterday by Tahira from web

reply

forward